Visualization that works: picture the dream, then the obstacle
Every vision book tells you to picture what you want. Hardly any of them mention the catch: done the wrong way, visualization can make you less likely to get it.
The problem with positive fantasies
Gabriele Oettingen, a psychology professor at New York University, spent two decades studying what happens when people dream about the future. In study after study, the people who indulged in the most positive fantasies often did worse: graduates who daydreamed most about landing a great job got fewer offers, and dieters who pictured themselves slim lost less weight.
Her explanation is simple. A vivid fantasy feels a little like having it already. Your mind relaxes, and the energy you'd need to go after it quietly drains away. She sets this out in her book Rethinking Positive Thinking (2014).
That doesn't mean you should stop dreaming. It means the dream needs a partner.
Mental contrasting: the dream, then the obstacle
Oettingen found that what works is mental contrasting: picture the outcome you want, then picture the main thing in the way. The contrast tells your brain two things at once: this matters, and here's what stands between you and it. When the goal is realistic, that's what gets you moving.
Roxie Nafousi gets at the same idea from the manifesting side. In Manifest, step two is removing fear and doubt, and step four is overcoming what she calls "tests from the universe": setbacks and rejections you meet as a chance to learn, not as a sign to quit. Mental contrasting is a practical way to meet the test before it arrives.
WOOP, step by step
- Wish. Pick something important to you that's challenging but possible. For a big vision, choose the next piece of it: a wish for this month, not the whole life.
- Outcome. What's the single best thing about getting it? Close your eyes and picture it for a moment. Make it vivid.
- Obstacle. What's the main thing inside you that gets in the way? Not the economy or other people, but your habit, your fear, the moment you reach for your phone. Picture that too.
- Plan. Decide one action for when that obstacle shows up, and say it as an if-then: "If obstacle, then I will action."
The if-then step is its own well-studied technique, called implementation intentions. We go deeper on it in How to stick to your vision.
Try it: your WOOP in four boxes
Nothing you type here leaves your browser.
Making it a daily habit
WOOP is a few minutes, once per wish. The daily habit can be much shorter:
- One scene, ten seconds. Close your eyes and see one moment from the life you're building, in detail.
- One look at the obstacle. Remember the thing most likely to get in your way today.
- One if-then. Say your plan for it.
This is the rhythm of a moment in Vision Charger. The app shows you a scene from your own vision when you reach for a scroll app, and every so often asks about what's in your way. It doesn't replace the work. It moves your attention back to it at the moment you're most likely to drift.
"Cherish your visions; cherish your ideals; cherish the music that stirs in your heart, the beauty that forms in your mind, the loveliness that drapes your purest thoughts, for out of them will grow all delightful conditions, all, heavenly environment; of these, if you but remain true to them, your world will at last be built."
James Allen, As a Man Thinketh (1903)
"If you but remain true to them" is the part most people skip. Mental contrasting is how you stay true to them on an ordinary Wednesday.
Write yours now, free
Give the vision builder a few sentences in your own words. It shows you what your vision stands for, lines to read every day and scenes to picture.
Build my visionThe books behind this guide
The research on positive fantasies, mental contrasting and WOOP. There's a free WOOP guide and app at woopmylife.org.
Removing fear and doubt, and treating setbacks as tests to get through rather than signs to stop.
Public domain. The chapter "Visions and Ideals".
Questions
Does visualization actually work?
It depends how you do it. Research by Gabriele Oettingen found that indulging in positive fantasies on their own was often linked to less effort and worse results. Picturing the outcome and then the obstacle in your way, a method called mental contrasting, was linked to more effort and better follow-through.
What does WOOP stand for?
Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan. Name a wish, picture the best outcome, picture the main obstacle inside you, then make an if-then plan for when that obstacle shows up.
How long should I visualize for?
A few minutes is enough. For the daily habit, ten to thirty seconds on one vivid scene works well, as long as you also know your obstacle and your plan for it.
Is this the same as manifesting?
It overlaps. Manifesting books like Roxie Nafousi's Manifest pair the vision with removing doubt and changing behaviour, and treat setbacks as tests to get through. Mental contrasting gives that a research-backed structure.
Sources
- Oettingen, G. (2014). Rethinking Positive Thinking. Current.
- Oettingen, G., & Mayer, D. (2002). The motivating function of thinking about the future: Expectations versus fantasies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(5), 1198–1212.
- Oettingen, G., & Gollwitzer, P. M. (2019). From feeling good to doing good.
- Allen, J. (1903). As a Man Thinketh. Project Gutenberg
Next: How to stick to your vision: 12-week goals and if-then plans →